CITIZEN LAB RESEARCH REPORT NO.151
25
Law Enforcement and Intelligence Services’ Response to
Digital Transnational Repression
Participants reached out to Canadian law enforcement bodies or the Canadian Security
Intelligence Agency (CSIS) for assistance and had mixed reactions to these interactions.94
Participants appeared frustrated with the lack of governmental assistance and felt like
they were forced to deal with digital transnational repression alone. They sometimes
decided not to approach law enforcement because they thought doing so might make
the situation worse, or they assumed law enforcement would simply be ineffective.
For example, a Yemeni activist reported the swapping of their Canadian SIM card and the
hacking of their bank account to the police, but they never received a reply. One participant from Hong Kong (previously identified as Li) raised the issue of digital transnational
repression with high-level officials in the Canadian government, but she felt that there
was no recognition or support for Canadians who faced such concerns.
An activist from Balochistan spoke to both the police and CSIS but was left with the feeling
that they had to address the issue alone. An activist from East Turkestan told the police
that they were being harassed through repeated phone calls, but the police said they
could not do anything because the calls were from an international number. Further, in
response to the participant’s concerns regarding digital security issues on their advocacy
blog, the police said the participant could hire a private detective.
Participants simply avoided dealing with the police, fearing that it might make the situation worse or that they could not be of assistance. For example, after his business was
the subject of extensive DDoS attacks, a Syrian business owner and activist (identified
as Amir, below) stated that he did not reach out to the police because he assumed that
the police would not be able to assist. A social and political activist from Afghanistan
explained that they did not approach the police after being digitally targeted because
they did not trust Canadian authorities. A pro-democracy activist from Hong Kong (previously identified as Li) said that she avoided approaching the police because it would
have been “useless.”
94
The participant has been assigned a pseudonym to protect their identity.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents