DEFENDING
DEMOCRACY IN EXILE
Policy Responses to
Transnational Repression
Autocrats cast a long shadow onto America’s soil. Alinejad’s
experience, although shocking, is not isolated. Attacks
against foreign dissidents living in the United States have
taken place since at least the 1950s, but operations by
foreign intelligence agents have significantly intensified in
recent years. The governments of Iran, China, Egypt, Russia,
Rwanda, Saudi Arabia, and other states are increasingly and
more aggressively disregarding US laws to threaten, harass,
surveil, stalk, and even plot to physically harm people across
the country.
Far from being a foreign problem,
transnational repression impacts the
lives and freedoms of people living in
the United States.
By reaching across national borders to silence dissent, these
governments are engaging in transnational repression.
Potential targets of transnational repression in the United
States include people who support human rights and
democracy in their former homelands, and those who
advocate for the well-being of friends and family they left
behind.4 Far from being a foreign problem, transnational
repression impacts the lives and freedoms of people
living in the United States. It violates their right to privacy,
free expression, and free movement. The violence and
harassment directed by authoritarian governments is not just
a problem for the targeted individuals. Hindering their rights
and freedoms has direct consequences for the quality of
America’s democracy and institutions.
Authorities, particularly at the federal level, are increasingly
aware of the threat of transnational repression within the
United States, and have taken steps to prevent the worst of
it: assassination attempts, rendition, and assault. However,
property damage, stalking, and intimidation still occur, causing
severe disruption to people’s lives. The Departments of
Homeland Security, Justice, and State, as well as the Federal
Bureau of Investigation (FBI) are part of a recently launched
“whole-of-government” approach to this issue, which is being
coordinated by the National Security Council. Significant
effort has been expended to make federal law enforcement
practices more responsive to the threat of transnational
repression, deploy targeted sanctions to hold perpetrators
accountable, and prosecute those engaging in the most
aggressive campaigns. Important action has also been taken
by Congress, including passage of legislation to help end the
authoritarian practice of misusing Interpol to target critics.
However, more remains to be done, especially with regard
to America’s immigration system, which is overwhelmed,
understaffed, and vulnerable to exploitation by foreign
governments. The costs of security cooperation and
arms trade between the United States and governments
that perpetrate transnational repression have also largely
escaped scrutiny. The next phase in addressing the threat
of transnational repression must ensure that America’s
own institutions and practices cannot be easily co-opted
by authoritarian states seeking to harm political exiles
and diasporas.
Suggested citation: Yana Gorokhovskaia and Isabel Linzer, “Unsafe in America: Transnational Repression in the United States,”
in Defending Democracy in Exile: Policy Responses to Transnational Repression (Washington, DC: Freedom House, June 2022),
https://freedomhouse.org/report/transnational-repression/united-states.
2
@FreedomHouse
#TransnationalRepression