Freedom House
Exporting authoritarianism: The effects of
transnational repression in the United States
F
or this report, Freedom House interviewed 12 people living
in the United States—citizens, permanent residents, and
asylum seekers—who were targeted by foreign governments.
Some of the people interviewed received threatening messages
via phone calls and texts, or online. Others were surveilled
at home or at work by people they suspected of working for
foreign governments. Their family members abroad were
intimidated. They were approached in public spaces or at
events by strangers who urged them in menacing terms to stop
their activism, or attempted to record them secretly. In at least
one case, a targeted individual’s private property was damaged.
Although their experiences varied, transnational repression—
especially when involving multiple tactics—stripped away
an individual’s sense of security. People experienced what
one US-based Saudi activist described as “psychological and
emotional warfare;” 5 an avalanche of threats, leaving their days
consumed with worry about the security of their family at
home and vulnerable relatives abroad.
Unsafe, even at home
Transnational repression engenders a deep sense of insecurity
in the people who experience it. Claude Gatebuke, a Rwandan
activist, received many threatening online, text, and phone
messages since he began his activism against the regime of
President Paul Kagame in the mid-2000s. Some messages
called him a “traitor” or a “liar.” Others warned that he would
be physically hurt. Some, including “We know the bullet that’s
going to take you out,” left a lasting impression.
Sardar Pashaei, a former champion wrestler and coach from
Iran, started a campaign to save a fellow wrestler, Navid Afkari,
back in Iran from a death sentence in 2020. The young man
was accused of murder and participating in protests. Forced to
confess under torture, he was eventually executed. Pashaei’s
support of his fellow athlete and his outspokenness about the
discrimination that minority and female athletic competitors
face in Iran has spurred reprisals by Iranian authorities.
Pashaei’s elderly parents and teenage niece in Iran have been
repeatedly threatened and warned about the consequences of
his activism. He has noticed strange men watching his home
in Virginia. Pashaei knows that other Iranian activists living in
the United States had been warned by the FBI that they are in
danger of being kidnapped by the Iranian state. The looming
threats have affected Pashaei’s daily life. He is worried about
the safety of his immediate family. “When you don’t feel safe
in your house in the US, that’s a disaster. That’s a shame…
Where else on this planet should we go to feel safe? Because all
our friends, they are dreaming of coming to the US. But now,
nobody feels safe.”
Intrusions into people’s private lives and homes are both
disturbing and common. Samuel Chu, a Hong Kong–born
American activist noticed a drone hover outside the windows
of his home, apparently looking through his windows with
a camera. Another activist targeted by China told Freedom
House that people in vehicles were surveilling the office
building as her organization was moving into it.
“When you don’t feel safe in your
house in the US, that’s a disaster.
That’s a shame.”
–Sardar Pashaei, Iranian-American activist
A Saudi activist campaigning for the release of a family member
held by Riyadh explained how the unending wave of threats
have made her hypervigilant. “This is my self-alarm. I have to be
very careful wherever I go, even in the US. If I see anything or
anyone suspicious, I always try to be careful. This is the sense
of feeling unsafe because of all of the threats, being monitored,
being stalked by the Saudi government. It’s all basically to
silence our voices.” 6
Mohamed Soltan, an Egyptian-American who grew up in
the Midwest, was imprisoned in Egypt for two years for
participating in protests that followed the military coup
against President Mohamed Morsi in 2013. Soltan, who
was released from prison in 2015, continued his activism
in the United States, most recently by filing a suit against
the Egyptian authorities for torturing him during his
imprisonment.7 In retaliation, Egyptian authorities have
imprisoned Soltan’s father and cousins.8 They have also
threatened him online, formally requested his extradition, and
freedomhouse.org
3