CASE STUDY: EXILED NICARAGUAN
HUMAN RIGHTS DEFENDERS IN COSTA RICA
almost 90% stated that harassment and surveillance was a
primary reason for leaving Nicaragua, followed by violence
(65%) and threats (50%).
Costa Rica provides comparatively ample protection for
migrants, and recently launched a new asylum category
for those fleeing from authoritarian regimes in Venezuela,
Cuba, and Nicaragua.9 The flow of migration since 2018 has
persisted until March 2020 when the border shut due to
the COVID-19 pandemic. Yet, migrant flows have begun to
increase in recent months. However, Costa Rica is struggling
to recover economically from the pandemic, particularly
within the tourist, service, and commercial industries where
most migrants and refugees find work. Most Nicaraguan
refugees find themselves in a precarious economic
situation, unable to find steady work, forcing many to resort
to informal work with low salaries. HRDs are often not
recognized as having different needs or characteristics from
the larger refugee population, either by organizations or
the Costa Rican population in general. Even for those who
continue to work in human rights describe their ability to
continue work is difficult, and many express experiencing
severe trauma as an exile, with remorse for not being able
to stay and remain fighting for human rights at home.
However, many Nicaraguan HRDs try to carry out their
work by investigating the laws and procedures in Costa Rica,
accompanying their compatriots in their efforts, sharing
knowledge, and giving advice.
There are support and protection options for HRDs and CSOs
in exile in Costa Rica, including a network of organizations
and institutions facilitated by the United Nations High
Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) that provide access
to vital services. These organizations include CENDEROS,
la Fundación Arias and SOS Derechos Humanos as well as
various Costa Rican municipalities. In our findings, only CEJIL
and the Shelter City Program work specifically in supporting
HRDs in exile. CEJIL works on filing complaints and reporting
while Shelter City offers an integrated program with housing,
medical and psychosocial support, training, and capacity
building. All available support and protection options for
Nicaraguan HRDs are operating at full capacity and cannot
keep pace with the growing demand. We believe that it is
necessary to seek support and accompaniment mechanisms
for HRDs that facilitate their subsistence and enhance the
implementation of their work to defend the human rights of
exiles and other Nicaraguan migrants who lack mechanisms
for complaint and demand for their rights in Costa Rica.
Acknowledgements
The research team wishes to acknowledge the assistance
and guidance provided by Freedom House’s Latin America
and Caribbean Team members Christopher Hill, Katie Turner,
Irina Ostrovenko, Jerusha Burnham, Aurelia Annino, and
Andrea Martalo. The Team thanks the key informants for their
time and for sharing valuable insights.
Costa Rica provides comparatively ample protection for migrants, and
recently launched a new asylum category for those fleeing from authoritarian
regimes in Venezuela, Cuba, and Nicaragua
4
@FreedomHouse